More than once in marina endicotts new novel, good to a fault, you might wonder if youve wandered into the world of barbara pym and her excellent. Thats the quote from elizabeth hay displayed on the cover of the copy of good to a fault freehand books, 2008 that i got out of the library. By utilizing challenging themes, realistic characters, and thoughtful pacing, endicott masterfully conveys these struggles. Overall, it as a good read, with both its positive and negative aspects. Theres heartbreak, theres joy, there are parts where you cryand its very high quality writing. The storytelling pace was good, even if interrupted by some difficulttoplace and difficulttocomprehend monologues. Hazel lancaster has thyroid cancer which is currently in a. Marina endicott looks at life and death through the compassionate, humane lens of a born novelist. How does their inclusion in the narrative enhance the book. Thinking about herself and the state of her soul, clara purdy drove to the bank one hot friday. The title is inspired by act 1, scene 2 of shakespeares play julius caesar, in which the nobleman cassius says to brutus. Its a good quote a succinct and accurate description of the novel.
Marina endicotts good to a fault wrings suspense and humor out of the everyday choices we make, revealing the delicate balance between sacrifice and selfinterest, between doing good and. Apr 03, 2014 its quite rare to get a book with this subject matter, and when you do you hope that it will be good. The fault, dear brutus, is not in our stars, but in ourselves, that we are underlings. What is so good about the novel the fault in our stars that. The thing about the fault in our stars is that it manages to tackle something as sensitive as cancer without being too cheesy. Mar 08, 2011 good to a fault is an ultimately joyful book that digs deep, with leavening humor, into questions of morality, class, and social responsibility. The gage family had been travelling to a new life in fort mcmurray, but bruises on the mother, lorraine, prove to be latestage cancer rather than remnants of the accident. If a critic of an authors first book uses both the phrases funny, wry and original and subtle, mature and highly original. Yet its this question of liability and damages automotive, spiritual, and otherwise that drives marina endicotts warm and witty second novel. Nov 17, 20 the fault in our stars is a fabulous book about a young teenage girl who has been diagnosed with lung cancer and attends a cancer support group. It is his fourth solo novel, and sixth novel overall.
The fault in our stars is a love novel starring hazel grace, a teen with terminal cancer who lives a quite a boring life, until she meets a guy, augustus walters, a charming, flirty guy. Harpercolltheres heartbreak, theres joy, there are parts where you cryand its very. Marina endicotts good to a fault comfortably resides in the sphere of moral ambiguity that lincoln articulated. Meg wolitzer, new york times bestselling author of the tenyear nap marina endicotts good to a fault wrings suspense and. Parents need to know that the fault in our stars is a story about teens fighting cancer, and sensitive readers might be uncomfortable with the subject matter and sometimes graphic. If a critic of an authors first book uses both the phrases funny, wry and original and subtle. Seventeenyearold hazel grace lancaster reluctantly attends a cancer patients support group at her mothers behest. The book the fault in our stars, by john green, is about two teens with cancer learning to embrace their lives and make the most of it. Good to a fault probably wont inspire spontaneous outbursts of goodness. Its just as funny and absorbing as her debut, open arms.
Margaret atwood unpretentious and affecting, with characters to remember and themes that linger and resound. Buy a cheap copy of good to a fault book by marina endicott. Good to a fault is peppered with quotations from poets gerard manley hopkins and dylan thomas, in particular, figure prominently. It was shortlisted for the 2008 giller prize in canada, and won the 2009 commonwealth writers prize for canada and the caribbean. The canadian writer marina endicotts second novel, good to a fault, won a commonwealth writers prize, and one can see why. Good to a fault by marina endicott book club discussion. With a theatrical sensibility, endicott, an established playwright and dramaturge, beautifully illuminates the interior lives and stunted interactions of her cast of struggling strangers all of whom, it turns out, are perfect fits for the mysterious holes in one anothers lives. Marina endicott when bruises on the mother, lorraine, prove to be latestage cancer, 43yearold clara purdy moves the three children and their terrible grandmother into her own house while lorraine undergoes. But, it will leave the reader thinking about the nature of goodness, which in itself is a very good reflection to. This book was very inappropriate i dont know why parents are telling you its for 14 and year olds its for adults.
Good to a fault is an ultimately joyful book that digs deep, with leavening humor, into questions of morality, class, and social responsibility. More than once in marina endicotts new novel, good to a fault, you might wonder if youve wandered into the world of barbara pym and her. Sometimes they disappoint you, but i promise the fault in our stars does not. In a moment of selfabsorption, clara purdys life takes a sharp l. Page 1 chapter one late in the winter of my seventeenth year, my mother decided i was depressed, presumably because i rarely left the house, spent quite a lot of time in bed, read the same book over and over, ate infrequently, and devoted quite a bit of my abundant free time to thinking about death. The question and answer section for the fault in our stars is a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel.
Endicott cleverly sets up what appears on the surface to be a clear cut act of. Good to a fault, by marina endicott the independent. The fault in our stars is a fabulous book about a young teenage girl who has been diagnosed with lung cancer and attends a cancer support group. It was shortlisted for the 2008 giller prize in canada, and won the 2009.
Marina endicott looks at life and death through the. The fault in our stars currently has a rating of 4. Ive seen so much hype about the fault in our stars in the blogosphere and, well, in life. It was shortlisted for the 2008 giller prize, longlisted for the dublin impac prize, and was featured on cbc radios canada reads in 2010. Jul 04, 2014 the thing about the fault in our stars is that it manages to tackle something as sensitive as cancer without being too cheesy. It has tons of sexual content such as virgins and references like stick the line in the hole,it has 2 descriptive pages of teens having oral sexhe was pinching her nipple and they were moaning,i sucked it it tasted so good. Its quite rare to get a book with this subject matter, and when you do you hope that it will be good. Jul 01, 2008 good to a fault is the anz litlovers reading group choice for august, and its a wonderful book for discussion. This is a reading list for people who dont have time for unimportant books. Endicott cleverly sets up what appears on the surface to be a clear cut act of goodness.
What does an imperial affliction have to do with hazels own life. The fault in our stars john green read online free books. Marina endicotts good to a fault wrings suspense and humor out of the everyday choices we make, revealing the delicate balance between sacrifice and selfinterest, between doing good and being. The page is a reading list sharing the best books to read in various categories based on many hours of reading and research. With a theatrical sensibility, endicott, an established playwright and dramaturge, beautifully illuminates the interior lives and stunted interactions of her cast. Canadian writer endicotts second novel and stateside debut is an enjoyable and affirming meditation on altruism, goodness, and loneliness. Good to a fault is the anz litlovers reading group choice for august, and its a wonderful book for discussion. Marina endicotts critically and commercially beloved novel, published for the first time by anchor canada. According to the book natural hazards, most geologist consider a particular fault to be an active fault if it has not moved during the past 10,000 years of the holocene epoch.
It has tons of sexual content such as virgins and references like stick the line in. Thus, its refreshing to find a book that accurately portrays that moral uncertainty which most of us deal with whether we realize it or not. It was shortlisted for the 2008 giller prize, longlisted for the dublin impac prize, and was featured on. Good to a fault by marina endicott penguin random house canada. Good to a fault revolves around clara purdy, single, childless of course, took care with her appearance. What is so good about the novel the fault in our stars. Sep 01, 2008 marina endicotts good to a fault comfortably resides in the sphere of moral ambiguity that lincoln articulated. The fault in our stars can teach these 7 real life lessons. Will build vocabulary and awareness of literature, as the book makes references to shakespeare, etc. Patrick gale good to a fault is one of those novels you want to tell people about. Youll find more than 100 good books to read, organized by category.
Hazel is 16 and is reluctant to go to the support group, but she soon realises that it was a good idea. Good to a fault book edmonton public library bibliocommons. In a moment of selfabsorption, clara purdys life takes a sharp left turn when she crashes into a beatup car carrying an itinerant family of six. Considering this book is also by the author of the fault in our stars, i think its clear that this should definitely be on your reading list. Marina endicott absorbed in her own failings, clara purdy crashes her life into a sharp left turn, taking the young family in the other car along with her. Marina endicotts good to a fault wrings suspense and humor out of the everyday choices we make, revealing the delicate balance between sacrifice and selfinterest, between doing good and being good. Good to a fault was a finalist for the giller prize, usually a sign that a book is well written and deserves to be read. I only list the best books to read in each category. Nov 19, 2014 the fault in our stars is a fabulous book about a young teenage girl who has been diagnosed with lung cancer and attends a cancer support group. It doesnt aspire to inspire or motivate, it just tells a story. It was shortlisted for the 2008 giller prize in canada, and won the 2009 commonwealth.
Im sure if youre not looking for perfection you would find the fault in our stars equally great. Good to a fault is an ultimately joyful look that digs deep, with leavening humor, into questions of morality, class, and social responsibility. Good to a fault book austin public library bibliocommons. Heres an outtake from good to a fault, featuring the irascible mrs. Jun 15, 2012 thats the quote from elizabeth hay displayed on the cover of the copy of good to a fault freehand books, 2008 that i got out of the library.
Good to a fault book menlo park library bibliocommons. Good to a fault won the 2009 commonwealth writers prize for best book, canadacaribbean region. In a moment of selfabsorption, clara purdys life takes a sharp left turn when she crashes into a beatup car carrying an. Marina endicott when bruises on the mother, lorraine, prove to be latestage cancer, 43yearold clara purdy moves the three children and their terrible grandmother. In the vein of the novels of carol shields and ann patchett, good to a fault is a witty, wise. Can inspire discussions about fate, the meaning of life, thoughts about dying. Good to a fault book by marina endicott thriftbooks. Good to a fault marina endicott book uncorrected proof. May 2009 kylee stoor fiction good to a fault by marina endicott. Bring on the tough stuff theres not just one right answer.
952 1422 36 23 1099 710 371 1218 498 1091 420 1348 1578 1403 58 337 1079 659 804 303 1227 981 991 635 1524 715 512 1109 138 539 809 316 269 463 1019 1301 661 1413 1216 82 1071 368 470 481 1171 541 1443 1117 179